Background Screening Blog

How To Spot a Screening Company Dedicated to Consumer Privacy

Written by Verified Credentials | Jul 28, 2026 2:00:03 PM

The industry knowledge contained in this article is provided by our featured contributor, Mike Mellskog. Mike is the IT Systems Manager at Verified Credentials, with 11+ years of experience ensuring our technology is safe, secure, and reliable.

 

In an era of increasing cyber threats, evolving privacy regulations, and growing public awareness of data protection, safeguarding consumer information is no longer just a compliance requirement; it’s a fundamental business responsibility.

Background screening providers handle some of the most sensitive personal information, including Social Security numbers, employment histories, criminal records, financial data, and other personally identifiable information (PII). A single security incident can have far-reaching consequences, affecting not only the individuals whose information is compromised but also the employers and partners who rely on the integrity of the hiring process.

As organizations continue to embrace digital hiring and interconnected technology platforms, robust consumer data security practices have become crucial. Strong cybersecurity measures, transparent data governance, and commitment to privacy help protect consumers, strengthen client confidence, and reinforce the trust that underpins every stage of the employment screening process.

Because consumer privacy practices are multifaceted, there are several ways to determine if the screening company you are considering is committed to maintaining consumer privacy. Keep reading for a quick guide to identifying screening companies that adhere to acceptable consumer privacy standards.

 

Credibility and qualifications for handling consumer data

Screening providers are subject to rigorous data-handling standards and are often eager to display their certifications and achievements. Companies are often transparent about compliance practices to demonstrate their ability to meet or exceed industry standards.  

What certifications do they carry?

While there are many state- or industry-specific data handling certifications, common certifications include the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA) Certification and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants System and Organization Controls (AICPA SOC) Attestation. These certifications can be identified by the following logos often found on a screening company’s website or official documents:

PBSA Accreditation

Although it is a voluntary accreditation, most employers, compliance officers, and industry stakeholders consider Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA) standards to be the benchmark for responsible background screening. PBSA’s Background Screening Agency Accreditation Program (BSAAP) measures several factors for compliance; those focused on consumer privacy include:

  • Data security and confidentiality procedures
  • Research methods and data verification processes
  • Legal and regulatory compliance adherence

A PBSA accreditation is intended to confirm that a screening provider effectively handles consumer data while minimizing risk and maintaining compliance and accuracy.

AICPA SOC Attestation 

AICPA SOC Attestations are conducted by independent CPA firms and evaluate an organization’s systems for managing data security, confidentiality, and operational controls. This demonstrates that the organization has acceptable policies and systems in place to safeguard PII, confidential employment data, and legally protected records. It also confirms that security and operational integrity standards have been met.

NIST 800-53

The National Institute of Standards (NIST) Special Publication 800-53 (NIST 800-53) provides a catalog of privacy and security controls for information systems. Many prominent security frameworks are derived from or heavily rely on NIST 800-53 as a technical control baseline, as it serves as the foundational catalog of security controls for the U.S. federal government. Key design features that lend to its applicability across systems include:

  • Privacy Integration – Privacy and security controls are integrated in a unified catalog to protect system integrity and personally identifiable information.
  • Risk-Based Approach – Using control baselines (Low, Moderate, High) rather than a rigid checklist helps organizations choose the correct safeguards for their specific risk levels.
  • Technology Neutrality – Guidelines are focused on security outcomes rather than dictating specific vendors or technologies, enabling adaptation across cloud environments, legacy systems, and modern IT infrastructure.
  • Foundation for Other Frameworks – Many other regulatory standards, including FISMA, FedRAMP, and CMMC, treat it as the underlying control library for security regulations.

There is no official certification available for NIST 800-53 compliance; organizations may receive and display a Letter of Attestation from a third-party audit confirming adherence to the publication framework.

TRUSTe Enterprise Privacy

The TRUSTe Enterprise Privacy Certification is one of many privacy certification standards offered by TrustArc. Companies displaying the TRUSTe Certified Privacy seal have demonstrated that their privacy policies and practices meet the TRUSTe Enterprise Privacy & Data Governance Practices Assessment Criteria.

TX-RAMP

The Texas Risk and Authorization Management Program (TX-RAMP) is a Department of Information Resources (DIR) program that reviews security measures taken by cloud products and services that transmit data to Texas state agencies. To be accepted into the program, cloud providers must comply with an established DIR framework and continuous compliance.

How do they adhere to regulatory compliance? 

Regulatory compliance for consumer reporting agencies (CRAs) is determined by many influences, including state laws, international standards, and Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) requirements. Ideally, your screening partner would be well-versed in all three, with systematic operations in place to meet the standards for each.

Some major consumer data processing-related requirements and compliance standards to note include:

  • Obtaining consent for data collection: This includes providing clear disclosure and authorization documents, collecting only necessary and relevant data, and implementing sensible policies and transparent communication about what is collected, how it’s used, and retention periods.
  • Upholding consumer rights protections: This includes providing consumers with access to their completed file within 30 days of it being requested, using clearly displayed and easy-to-use opt-out mechanisms, notifying all parties who have received inaccurate reports, and promptly applying data corrections received from the consumer.

 

Data security and encryption measures

Below are some policies, procedures, and concepts that organizations handling consumer data may apply to help stay secure.

Data Retention Policies
  • Clear retention schedules based on legal standards, set and understood by all parties handling data
  • Automated deletion functions that are activated after set retention periods
  • Methods for secure record disposal
  • System for establishing audit trails for record destruction procedures
Quick Incident Response Times
  • Utilizing real-time monitoring and alerts
  • Establishing a 30-day breach notification requirement (FTC)
  • Documenting procedures from incident response practice drills and actual cases
Effective Access Controls
  • Granting relevant levels of role-based access to data
  • Implementing multi-factor authentication (MFA) steps
  • Immediately removing employee access to data upon termination
  • Continuous monitoring and audit logging
Properly Encrypting Data
  • Establishing encrypted backups and audit logs
  • Utilizing specific encryption types for stored, “at rest” data (AES-256) and data in transit (TLS 1.2+)
  • Regularly updating and patching systems

 

More to consider

There’s no question that employees need to undergo a thorough background screening before receiving access to consumer data, but some organizations handling extremely sensitive or personally identifiable data may want to go the extra mile to ensure data security. By continuously monitoring the staff members responsible for processing, accessing, interpreting, storing, and deleting consumer data, these organizations can ensure their staff keep pace with ever-changing compliance requirements and remain qualified to manage sensitive data.

Want to conveniently track legislation affecting data collection, privacy, and usage?

>> Follow the Verified Credential Industry Newsletter for seasonal compliance updates.